Republicans and Their Missed Opportunity on Obamacare

What if House Republicans had made the government shutdown contingent on only delaying the Individual Mandate, and withdrawal of Congress’ subsidies and exemptions under Obamacare?

Imagine Ted Cruz and Mike Lee didn’t launch a war that couldn’t be won, and instead focused on one that could.  Imagine the bright light that would have been shone onto the debacle that is Obamacare.  The Republicans would have won that battle and been on the road to more victories, including potentially both the House and Senate in the 2014 elections.

Here are the 2 arguments they should have made, both of which they would have won, at least in the minds of the American voting public:

1.  Delay the Individual Mandate until January of 2015.

The argument would go like this.  President Obama, in deference to American businesses (read “special interests with lobbying groups in Washington”), already delayed the Corporate Mandate until January of 2015.  Why, then, not do the same for the American citizenry (read “people without lobbyists in Washington”)?  The Corporate Mandate fines companies of over 50 employees an amount of $2,000 for each employee not provided health insurance.  The Individual Mandate fines (taxes) individuals who do not buy insurance.  Republicans arguing that individuals should get the same time delay as corporations was a certain winner.  Why didn’t they choose this path?

2.  Require that all members of the House and Senate, and the President, use the Obamacare Exchanges without subsidies.

Once again, imagine the Republicans arguing “if the Exchanges are good enough for the American citizenry, why aren’t they good enough for those in government leadership?”  What would be Obama, Pelosi, Reid, and Sebelius’ argument against such a policy?  Of course, their unspoken argument would be “We don’t want to be subject to the Exchanges because they are more expensive out of pocket than the cushy Federal benefits we have today, and we probably won’t be able to keep our doctors, and the coverage is less comprehensive”.  The fact is, in the minds of Democrat leaders in Washington, the Exchanges are good enough for the Proletariat, but not for the king and his subjects.  

Republicans would have won in both arguments, and the hypocrisy and falsehoods of Obamacare would be much more well known by the public today, and a heavy dose of fairness would have been cast.  Instead, Republicans chose the wrong path and lost in every category that matters.  

 

 

 

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Republicans and Their Missed Opportunity on Obamacare

  1. Bueti, Rick says:

    Dan, you’re right. I was hoping the Republicans would offer no resistance to Obamacare, let it implode, and then say “I told you so.” Instead, they tried to repeal and defund it and they took the hit for shutting down the government. What a disaster.

    However, you are giving the American public way too much credit in terms of understanding the Obamacare disaster. Remember, the guy that Jesse Watters interviewed in Chappaqua thought Benghazi was a person, and not one woman that Watters interviewed could give a specific reason on why they love Hillary and would vote for her. That’s how out of touch most of our citizens are.

    Rick Bueti
    Leasing Sales Representative
    Avnet Technology Solutions
    280 South Bedford Road
    Chappaqua, NY 10514
    Office: (914)-861-2108
    Cell: (914)-299-6094
    Rick.Bueti@Avnet.com

  2. william fris says:

    I agree with both of you. As this monster (ACA) evolves I just found out a lot of individuals are being forced into the plan because their plan doesn’t hit the “Gov Min standards” so unlike what the President lead us to believe some are being forced out of their existing plans to go into the exchange which will mean either higher or lower premiums based on the employees income. But the bottom line is you are now being fed a prescribed Health insurance package not truly choosing one that suits your needs or budget . Big Brother knows best!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s